Pittsburgh, the Steel City, is a metropolis that embodies grit and resilience, much like its people. Its burger scene is a hidden gem, packing a flavorful punch that rivals its industrial heritage. I discovered a thriving culinary landscape serving burgers as bold and satisfying as the city itself.
The Burgers
Pittsburgh's burger scene may not be as flashy as other cities, but it packs a punch. I set out to explore the city's best burger spots, and here are the highlights from my culinary adventure:
Moonlit Burgers: With two convenient locations, this modern smash burger spot is a must-visit spot for burger enthusiasts. Their Uptown location, nestled between college and PPG Paints Arena, is a prime destination for arena visitors, students, and locals alike. The atmosphere is bright and welcoming, featuring a spacious interior with ample seating options, TVs, and a full bar. Their Classic Moonlit Double is a quintessential Oklahoma-style smash burger with their signature moon sauce on a Martin's potato roll. This masterpiece showcases a perfect ingredient ratio and exceptional chew, earning its place as one of the best burgers anywhere. Alternatively, the #4 Best Seller amplifies the original with slaw, fries, and hot sauce, but beware – this heavy, belly-buster isn’t for everyone. Their Smash Fries are exceptional, absolutely loaded with cheese, moon sauce, and pickled jalapenos, creating a harmonious flavor medley. Even the unassuming shoestring fries shine on their own, proving that looks can be deceiving. Do yourself a favor and head to Moonlit.
Red’s Good News: This is the ultimate neighborhood hangout, where good news reigns supreme. Owned by two visionary cousins, this vibrant spot showcases their creative touch in every detail, from original artwork and dynamic themed installations to the eclectic schematics adorning the bar. With warm hospitality and an infectious patriotic atmosphere, Red's Good News invites you to linger, relax, and return again and again, making it a true community gem. The burger features two beefy smash patties topped with small slices of cheese, sauteed onions, and a tangy BBQ sauce, all between a buttery and squishy white bun. But don't stop there - the chicken fingers are a must-order, featuring super thick breading giving way to juicy, tender meat. They are served with an addictive White Lightning dip, a game-changer that's absolute perfection. Pro-tip: Drizzle White Lightning on your burger for a match made in heaven, elevating the BBQ sauce to new heights! Red's Good News is a must-visit destination for anyone visiting The 'Burgh.
The Commoner: This upscale but casual spot inside the Kimpton Monaco Hotel offers a mouth-watering off-the-menu gem. The coveted Wagyu beef double smash burger features American cheese, caramelized onions, secret sauce, and sweet pickles on a Martin's potato roll. The burger is well balanced with the right ratios and a balance of sweetness from the pickles and onions. The fries come in a huge portion and with a super unique garlic aioli that's akin to a savory, garlicky cheese sauce.
Tessaro’s American Bar & Hardwood Grill: A timeless local landmark, Tessaro's unique selling point is that their meat is ground fresh daily by their in-house butcher and then expertly grilled over hardwood on a custom-made cast iron grill. Inside, the classic American setting transports you to a bygone era, complete with black and red checkered floors, blue tablecloths, and red placemats. Their menu offers various burger options, most customizable to your liking. I opted for the Bacon & Bleu Burger, featuring pungent hard blue cheese. Served on a hearty white bun, the burger delivers rich, smoky flavors and a tender texture thanks to its signature grilling process. The flavors and textures harmonize perfectly. Sides are plentiful, with options like home fries, coleslaw, broccoli, and more - but no French fries.
Primanti Brothers: An institution thats an obligatory stop in Pittsburgh, especially for first-timers. That being said, the Pitts-burger and their “almost famous sandwiches” just don’t do it for me. They have many locations scattered throughout the city and are also at the airport.
All of the rest are on my radar, in order of my excitement, to try them:
The Monterey Pub
Bridge City Brinery - food truck
Pittsburgh Sandwich Society - food truck
Jamison’s
Over the Bar Bicycle Cafe
St. Clair Social
Scratch & Co
Simply Burgers
The Brinery
Eleven
Special thanks to the Alex Eats Too Much’s Pittsburgh Burger List, which helped shape my burger journey.
Everything Else
Look beyond the surface, and you'll find Pittsburgh to be a surprisingly lively and diverse city, full of unexpected delights and exciting experiences.
Running: The Ohio, Allegheny, and Monongahela rivers provide stunning waterfront paths while Schenley Park and beyond offers picturesque routes and lengthy strips for a satisfying jog.
The Food Scene: From classic pierogies and kielbasa to innovative eateries and food trucks, the city offers a diverse dining experience. Notable spots to explore, as recommended by locals, include Pierogies Plus, S&D Polish Deli, Gaucho Parrilla Argentina, and Legume.
Arts & Sightseeing: Explore the city's artistic side at The Andy Warhol Museum, showcasing the iconic artist's life and work. Take in panoramic views of the skyline from Mount Washington, accessible via the historic Monongahela Incline.
Professional Sports: Pittsburgh's passionate fan base fuels its reputation as a sports hub, led by the Steelers, Penguins, and Pirates. Catch a Pirates game and enjoy the beloved Pierogi Race, featuring Jalapeño Hannah, during the 5th inning.
The Hotel
My stay at The Industrialist Hotel (Marriott Autograph Collection) exceeded expectations. The lobby's grandeur, featuring veined marble, a bronze staircase, and black and white tiled floors, set the tone for a memorable experience. Here are a few highlights:
Location: Prime location centrally suited for easy exploration and walking distance to the sports venues.
The Building: Housed in the iconic and charming Arrott Building (1902), one of Pittsburgh's earliest skyscrapers, that’s listed on the National Register of Historic Places.
The Room: Features sleek, contemporary amenities, ensuring a comfortable stay.
Amenities: Connected to the hotel is the Rebel Room, a cozy bar and restaurant. The 4th Ave Smash Burger on their menu looks promising - next time…
Beyond its Steel City roots, Pittsburgh's burger scene and cultural landscape offer a rich blend of flavors, experiences, and warm hospitality. Come for the city, stay for the burgers.
