Frog Club
now closed
Frog Club has a reputation for being one of the city's most intriguing spots, housed in a location steeped in rich history. As a result, opinions about it vary widely, and it's become a topic of much debate and discussion. While it was once shrouded in mystery, my visit was less dramatic. Notably, it was after the no-photo policy had been lifted, and reservations were available on Resy (before that was done via email). Worth visiting? I think so.
The Burger: Hamburger with Whipped Butter (Tier 3). This burger is a true original, one of one. Usually, a burger is put in front of me and I know instinctively what to do, but not with this one. The appearance is non-traditional, featuring a homemade English muffin, butter, frog sauce, and no cheese. This English muffin is remarkably thick, with a soft interior full of nooks and crannies. Its consistency is reminiscent of a biscuit, offering a pleasant chew without scraping the roof of your mouth. The beautiful patty shines with a crispy exterior, a nicely charred crust, plenty of pepper, and high-quality meat cooked to a juicy medium rare. The absence of cheese is a testament to the meat's excellence. To enjoy this burger, simply butter it, add frog sauce, and indulge. The result is a dripping, savory masterpiece. The butter melts to perfection, dissolving instantly into the meat. The frog sauce, a cross between hot sauce and steak sauce, leans toward the former, with a flavor profile similar to Frank's RedHot. This burger is incredibly filling. The Sidewinder Fries are a delight, with a crispy exterior giving way to a soft, fluffy interior.
Pro Tip: For dessert, the banana chafon pie is the sole offering, but it's a standout. This airy, light treat features Nila wafers at the bottom, a graham cracker sprinkle, cherry on top, and chunks of banana. Delicious.
The Occasion & Vibe: Date Night / Reservations Recommended. The unique, exclusive feel is enhanced by tight quarters, a small bar, and limited tables. Dim lights and a green hue throughout create an intimate ambiance, while frog paintings and eclectic decor add character. The upbeat music and continuous flow between the dining room and bar maintain a lively yet relaxed vibe.A notable charm is the large stuffed animal frog, Bedford, who's available for photos.
The Location: West Village, 86 Bedford Street.
